ADVERTISEMENT

Subscribe to the PowerPulse Newsletter

Conferences and Forums

Darnell's Energy Summit

Darnell's Power Forum

Green Building Power Forum

Smart Grid Electronics Forum

Industry News

January 31, 2011

SynQor Patent Dispute Now Involves Cisco, Ericsson, and Vicor

Power Channels: Power Components

SynQor filed suit against Ericsson, Vicor, and Cisco on January 28th, 2011 for patent infringement related to the case recently decided in SynQor’s favor (SynQor vs. Artesyn Technologies Inc. et al). The latest SynQor legal action claims that "Ericsson and Vicor infringe the patents at issue in this action when they make, import, use, promote, offer to sell, and/or sell within the United States products including, but not limited to, unregulated and/or semi-regulated bus converters and/or POLs used in intermediate bus architecture power supply systems." The suit contends that Cisco, as a primary customer of Ericsson and Vicor, also infringes the patents at issue.

The SynQor action capped a busy week of legal challenges related to SynQor’s initial victory in the patent case. On January 24th, a Texas court ruled in favor of SynQor in its request for an immediate injunction against the eleven companies who had been found legally liable for infringing the patents at issue. Importantly, during its request for the injunction, SynQor had identified Cisco (not one of the initial defendants) as the primary customer of the infringing products, and then asked the court to require Cisco to outline the safeguards it would institute in order to avoid infringement themselves.

ADVERTISEMENT

Almost immediately, a judge in New York provided the original defendants a respite when he put the injunction "on hold." Then, on January 25th, Lineage Power (one of the original defendants) announced the release of a series of bus converter modules which the company said can be used as "drop-in upgrades for unregulated and semi-regulated bus converters challenged by recent industry-wide intellectual property issues." (emphasis ours). Lineage also noted that it would be attaching a statement to its products that had been affected by the injunction which made it clear that they were not intended for sale or use in, or importation into, the United States.

Cisco filed suit against SynQor in Delaware on January 26th, stating that Cisco had "a reasonable apprehension that SynQor will assert against it (Cisco) a claim that the systems or services supplied by Cisco infringe the Patents-in-Suit." Cisco also noted that in the original suit filed by SynQor against eleven of Cisco’s suppliers, SynQor had described these companies as the "indirect infringers," while Cisco and other customers were described as the "direct infringers." In its suit, Cisco claims that each of the patents in question is "invalid" and that each of them "is the subject of a pending inter partes reexamination."

The Cisco suit against SynQor was filed only hours after a similar suit had been filed by Vicor in Massachusetts. Vicor issued the following comment regarding their suit to PowerPulse:

Opinion: Unraveling the Ultra-Low Power Design Issues

"Vicor Bus Converters, utilizing Vicor’s own proprietary Sine Amplitude Converter™ technology, are fundamentally different from, and technologically superior to, bus converters made by SynQor Inc.. The limitations of claims asserted by SynQor do not apply to Vicor Bus Converters and Vicor is unaffected by a U.S. District Court injunction against manufacturers of bus converters that were found to infringe SynQor patents.

"Vicor has developed higher efficiency, pin-compatible upgrades for 5:1 and 4:1 eighth-bricks and quarter-bricks bus converters. These custom products, engineered at the request of certain customers, will soon be made available as standard products to address the needs of other customers suffering from industry-wide shortages caused by the injunction."

Share this story

Send via E-mail
Post to Twitter

On the Web:

Cisco Systems Inc.
Ericsson
SynQor Inc.
Vicor Corp.

ADVERTISEMENT

White Papers

March 11, 2013

Power Modules for Charger Applications

Sponsored by Vincotech

February 27, 2013

The Adaptive Cell Converter Topology Enables Constant Efficiency Over Universal Input AC Line in Front-End, High-Density Power Factor Correction Applications

Sponsored by Vicor Corp.

February 27, 2013

From 48 V direct to Intel VR12.0: Saving "Big Data" $500,000 per datacenter, per year

Sponsored by Vicor Corp.

More White Papers

Most Popular

Design Features

October 22, 2012

Energy Efficiency with Class D Amplifier Modules

Class-D switching amplifiers are helping audio designers create personal multimedia devices and home audio/visual systems that demonstrate how compact and stylish equipment can also deliver high sound quality and high audio output power. The key to this breakthrough, providing freedom from the large and bulky boxes housing traditional audio products, lies in the class-D amplifier’s high energy efficiency, which is typically around 90%. This allows designers to reduce or eliminate heatsinks as well as using smaller-sized PCBs and smaller components such as transformers, connectors and power supplies.

Read this paper

Design Features

October 8, 2012

The Role of Hall Effect Sensors in Power Distribution Infrastructure

Power distribution units (PDUs) form an essential part of modern computing and data communications hardware. They provide multiple outputs for transferring electrical power with maximum efficiency, controlling the power capacity and safeguarding against the possible causes of supply interruption. With an ever increasing need from tech savvy consumers for higher data throughput and greater quantities of data storage capacity, as well as tough international legislation now governing CO&sub2; emissions, the demands being placed on these units are proving challenging for engineering teams to satisfy.

Read this paper

Product Focus

August 13, 2012

The Year in AC-DC Power Supply Technology

The past year witnessed significant new product releases, technological developments, and industry news related to the field of AC-DC Power Supply technology.

Read this paper

Read More Technical Features

 

©2013 Darnell Group Inc.