.gif)
.gif)
Industry News
May 11, 2012
Competition in Wide-Bandgap Devices: a Technical Session at PCIM 2012
One of the highlights of the technical program at this year’s PCIM Europe event was a session on "Competition in Wide-Bandgap Devices" that focused on considerations for selecting SiC devices for power conversion applications. Among the companies making presentations were: Danfoss Solar Inverters, EADS, Fairchild Semiconductor and STMicroelectronics.
A team of engineers from Danfoss Solar Inverters in Denmark analyzed the switching and conducting performance of two types of SiC normally on JFETs – a SiC normally-off JFET, two types of SiC MOSFETs and a SiC-BJT from a variety of manufacturers including Cree, Fairchild, Infineon, SemiSouth and Rohm. They used measurements at exactly the same boundary conditions to compare the devices. In addition to comparing the switching and conducting behaviors of the devices, the team also compared the requirements for driving the devices. They concluded that identification of the "best" device depends strongly on the application, since all devices show advantages, but in different ways. Therefore a universally valid recommendation for one of these power semiconductors cannot be given.
The following is a portion of the Danfoss team’s analysis of characteristic for the depletion mode JFET (Normally-On JFET) is that it is turned on at a gate voltage of 0V: This characteristic leads to considerable efforts for the driver: if the JFET is directly driven, it must be ensured that the driver is also supplied with power in case of a failure on the ac or dc side, to hold the JFET in blocking state. If the JFET is directly driven, a gate voltage of -15V is required to block the device and 0V to hold the device in conducting state. For further reduction of the on resistance a positive voltage of up to 2V can be applied.
Related: Toshiba, APEC and Vicor Target DC-DC Applications
An alternative to drive the JFET directly is to operate it in a cascode. The advantage of the cascode is that the JFET can be driven as a conventional MOSFET. However this topology also has two disadvantages: first, a positive gate-source voltage cannot be applied to the JFET and therefore the optimum conducting performance cannot be achieved; second, the full dynamic potential cannot be utilized, because the switching performance is mainly given by the Si-MOSFET. This analysis noted that Semisouth and Infineon have introduced driver concepts in their application notes that combine the advantages of the cascode with the direct driven approach. Danfoss found that the effort for the driver thus increases considerably.
A team of researchers from EADS and Friedrich-Alexander University in Erlangen, Germany, focused on the behavior and performance of SiC body diodes and all-SiC switch/diode combinations regarding reverse recovery. To compare the influence of the different devices on the recovery behavior of the combined switch, several switch/diode-pairs are used. For the active switch the Cree SiC MOSFET technology was chosen. It is readily available in two different chip sizes: 80m (CMF20120D) and 160m (CMF10120D). For the diodes, SiC Schottky diodes from Semisouth were chosen with current ratings of 5A (SDA05S120), 10A (SDP10S120D), and 30A (SDP30S120).
Opinion: Maximising Synergies between Power Electronics and ICT for improving Energy Efficiency
Reverse recovery tests were performed with single SiC MOSFET body diodes and pairs of SiC MOSFETs with SiC Schottky diodes at different conditions. Key reverse recovery parameters were extracted and compared. The manufacturer of the selected MOSFETs does not recommend the use of their body diode because of its high forward voltage and accompanying conduction losses. The researchers found that this disadvantage could be omitted if the FET channel was used for reverse conduction. This work investigated the recovery performance of the body diode and also showed that it is advisable the use a Schottky diode in parallel with the FET. This significantly decreases the required switching energy, in extreme cases by nearly 37%. It was also shown that for further improved performance, a small Schottky diode is preferable.
Fairchild teamed up with the Center of Competence for Distributed Electric Power Technologies at the University of Kassel to study SiC bipolar transistors (BJTs). The team concluded that the BJT offers one of the best alternatives among the diverse existing SiC switch technologies, given the low specific chip resistance and low temperature dependence. In addition to this they verified that common drawbacks associated with Si-BJTs – like poor dynamic behavior, low gain and limited SOA – are not applicable when SiC is used as the base material.
The application of SiC BJTs in a switching power converter demonstration resulted in very good levels of efficiency without resorting to over dimensioning the system, i.e. connecting several devices in parallel. The use of a higher switching frequency along with a new core material enabled a significant reduction of the filter inductor, which was about one-quarter of the size of the reference system. The team claimed a potential for savings in hardware by having lower chip expenditure, lower level of losses (smaller heatsink) and smaller filter elements.
In the paper from STMicroelectronics, the company’s first 20A, 1,200V SiC MOSFET prototype was presented and compared with a 1200V normally-off SiC JFET and a 1200V SiC BJT. A complete dynamic comparison analysis among the three switches in the range 1 to 7A was presented with a special focus on each device driving needs at T=25°C. According to the paper, the results in terms of total dynamic losses (driving effort is not included) are clear and impressive: the SiC MOSFET shows around 55% less total dynamic losses than the SiC JFET and around 60% less than the SiC BJT driven with a negative voltage (percentages are calculated at Id=7A,T=25°C). An additional evaluation was performed at T=125°C and Id=7A: no significant degradation was observed, except for a slight worsening of the SiC JFET turn on energy (+20% if compared to the 25°C data).
The STMicroelectronics analysis found that despite its high Ron*A value, the SiC MOSFET was demonstrated to be the most promising switch among the others under evaluation, exhibiting total dynamic losses far lower than the SiC BJT and SiC JFET normally-off and a very simple drive approach, which makes the SiC MOSFET the best candidate in the high frequency, high efficiency power conversion context.
Share this story
Send via E-mail
Post to Twitter
On the Web:
Danfoss Solar Inverters
EADS
Fairchild Semiconductor
Infineon Technologies
PCIM Europe
STMicroelectronics Inc.
White Papers
March 11, 2013
Power Modules for Charger Applications
Sponsored by Vincotech
February 27, 2013
The Adaptive Cell Converter Topology Enables Constant Efficiency Over Universal Input AC Line in Front-End, High-Density Power Factor Correction Applications
Sponsored by Vicor Corp.
February 27, 2013
From 48 V direct to Intel VR12.0: Saving "Big Data" $500,000 per datacenter, per year
Sponsored by Vicor Corp.
More White Papers
- Altera Acquires Enpirion for $140 Million, Forms Power Business Unit
- Ericsson Saves Board Space with Surface-Mount Digital Bus Converter
- SiC Modules, IGBTs and Super-Junction MOSFETs Introduced on Day One of PCIM
- SiC and GaN Again a Major Focus at PCIM Europe
- PowerbyProxi Joins Wireless Power Consortium
- Vincotech and Infineon Introduce New Packaging Options at PCIM Europe
- Bosch Claims First Sub-$450 240V EV Charging Station
- DOE Selects Consortium to Develop Next-Generation Batteries for Automobiles
- Dana Receives Grant from NRCan to Improve Thermal Management for EV Battery Packs
- Eaton and CA Technologies Join to Deliver Infrastructure Management for Data Centers
- Power-One Gets $1 Billion – ABB Gets Inverters
- Renesas Adds IGBT Drivers with Micro-Isolator for Electric and Hybrid Vehicle Inverters
- European Project Reports Achievements in Drive to Shape the Future of Power Microelectronics
- Bosch Claims First Sub-$450 240V EV Charging Station
- Alpha and Omega Delivers "Lowest" On-Resistance in a DFN5x6 with 150V Power MOSFET
- Eltek Signs Agreement with Caterpillar on Telecom Hybrid Systems
- Altera Acquires Enpirion for $140 Million, Forms Power Business Unit
- LED Lighting Power & Dimming Controls Introduced by Phihong
- SL Packs 60 Watts of Industrial-Grade AC-DC Power in Small and Robust Package
- Eltek's New Rectifier Delivers 97.2% Efficiency for Data Center and Server Powering
- Green Building Power Forum 2010: Fujitsu Components America
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: CUI Incorporated
- Green Building Power Forum 2010: EMerge Alliance
- Green Building Power Forum 2010: Anderson Power Products
- Green Building Power Forum 2009: Independence Station
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: Coilcraft
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: Champs Technologies
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: EXAR Corporation
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: PMBus
- Darnell's Digital Power Forum 2009: Power Plaza
Design Features
October 22, 2012
Energy Efficiency with Class D Amplifier Modules
Class-D switching amplifiers are helping audio designers create personal multimedia devices and home audio/visual systems that demonstrate how compact and stylish equipment can also deliver high sound quality and high audio output power. The key to this breakthrough, providing freedom from the large and bulky boxes housing traditional audio products, lies in the class-D amplifier’s high energy efficiency, which is typically around 90%. This allows designers to reduce or eliminate heatsinks as well as using smaller-sized PCBs and smaller components such as transformers, connectors and power supplies.
Design Features
October 8, 2012
The Role of Hall Effect Sensors in Power Distribution Infrastructure
Power distribution units (PDUs) form an essential part of modern computing and data communications hardware. They provide multiple outputs for transferring electrical power with maximum efficiency, controlling the power capacity and safeguarding against the possible causes of supply interruption. With an ever increasing need from tech savvy consumers for higher data throughput and greater quantities of data storage capacity, as well as tough international legislation now governing CO&sub2; emissions, the demands being placed on these units are proving challenging for engineering teams to satisfy.
Product Focus
August 13, 2012
The Year in AC-DC Power Supply Technology
The past year witnessed significant new product releases, technological developments, and industry news related to the field of AC-DC Power Supply technology.